A use of force expert testified at the public hearing into the police-involved death of Myles Gray Thursday, breaking down the national use of force framework that was in place at the time of the fatal altercation.
Insp. Christopher Butler was brought in to testify on behalf of the officers involved. He says the goal is always to resolve conflicts without the use of force and communication is the way in which officers are trained to do that.
Ian Donaldson, lawyer for the Gray family, says that after hearing responding VPD officer Hardeep Sahota’s interview earlier in the hearing, he questions why the altercation ever got violent.
“It’s clear from what she described, he was a person who wasn’t violent but acting erratically,” Donaldson said.
“You have to ask yourself, why was there engagement to begin with? Because unfortunately once it started, it feels like the end was predetermined.”
Butler says research shows that if officers haven’t established control after about one minute of fighting, the risk and severity of injuries will increase substantially. He says that’s why officers are trained to use a level of force when needed that exceeds any resistance in order to gain control and end the struggle quickly.
An officer who testified in March said Gray was handcuffed and hobbled and struggled while being restrained face down by officers for several minutes before his body went limp.
On Wednesday, one of the officers involved — now Detective Cst. Nick Thompson — said he regrets describing police conduct during the altercation as “incredibly compassionate,” admitting that were the wrong choice of words.
“I can think of many more compassionate ways to deal with a mentally disturbed person dealing with an episode,” Donaldson said.
“It’s not the word I would choose.”
Thompson was also questioned about why he waited several days to write his notes about the incident, which were uploaded to a police database eight months after Gray’s death. Thompson said he was advised by the police union not to make notes before speaking with a lawyer, and only began writing his statement after meeting with a police psychologist.
This is similar to what we heard earlier this week from Cst. Beau Spencer, who said he was also advised not to take notes following the altercation — something that is standard practice for officers after an event of this nature happens.
The hearing will take a break after this week before resuming Nov. 30.
We are expected to hear from responding VPD Cst. Josh Wong in the coming weeks.